Read the evidence accurately

Accounts, documents and evidence: directory glossary

Understand account access, document versions, identifiers, test methods, travel conditions and indicators. 62 practical distinctions.

A persistent identifier, an index entry and a complete document have different roles. Use these distinctions to choose the missing evidence and avoid interpreting a label as a guarantee.

ISBN

An identifier for a book edition and product form. Compare number, language, publisher and edition; a matching check character does not establish assignment.

Bibliothèque nationale de France : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

ISSN

An identifier for a serial publication associated with its title and medium. It does not identify an individual article; print and online versions can have distinct ISSNs.

Bibliothèque nationale de France : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Findable DOI

A DataCite state in which the DOI is registered and its metadata is public through the API and DataCite Commons. It concerns record availability, not object quality.

DataCite : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Registered DOI

A DataCite state for a DOI registered in the Handle System whose metadata is not exposed by public search. Absence from Commons therefore does not establish absence of registration.

DataCite : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Draft record

A DataCite draft that can reserve an identifier without registering it in the Handle System. Distinguish record preparation from actual DOI publication.

DataCite : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

ROR ID

A persistent identifier for a research organization. Name variants, locations, statuses and relationships help match affiliations; the identifier does not authenticate a person.

Research Organization Registry (ROR) : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Wikidata rank

A preferred, normal or deprecated qualification for a statement. It helps select values; a reference is still needed to identify the source of the claim.

Wikidata : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

W3C Group Note

A document published as a stable reference without being intended as a formal standard. A Note and a Recommendation have different standing in the W3C process.

W3C : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Statistical dimension

An axis describing dataset observations, such as geography, unit, frequency or period. Read the dimensions of two values before comparing them.

Eurostat : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Rolling period

A selection defined by a number of recent periods, such as the last ten available years. Covered years can change: record actual dates to reproduce an analysis.

Eurostat : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Metadata quality score

A data.gouv.fr indicator based on descriptions, documentation, updates and licensing, among other criteria. It does not replace examining the data or its suitability for a question.

data.gouv.fr : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

PubMed query translation

Transformation of entered terms into the executed search, shown in Search Details. Quotes, tags and wildcards affect automatic mapping: retain the executed query as well.

PubMed : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Mastodon Quiet public

Visibility formerly called Unlisted: absent from public feeds and search but accessible on the profile and by direct link. The post remains public.

Mastodon : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

Scientific TLDR

A very short AI-generated summary helping discover a publication on Semantic Scholar. It differs from the authors’ abstract and does not replace the text’s methods and results.

Semantic Scholar : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

UN document symbol

An identifier combining letters and numbers, shared by language versions of a document. It generally does not indicate the subject: retain title, language and date as well.

Nations Unies : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

OpenAlex publication location

A place where a work is available, described in locations. Multiple locations may concern the same study: counting them as independent confirmations would be misleading.

OpenAlex : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗ · consulted on

ORCID check digit

The identifier’s final calculated character, a digit or X. Its consistency can detect some copying errors; it does not prove record assignment.

ORCID : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Zenodo concept DOI

An identifier grouping an object’s versions and pointing to its latest version. To document the files used, also retain the specific version DOI.

Zenodo : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Record-update date

A metadata-change date, distinct from publication or text revision. In OpenAlex, a citation-count change can also update it.

OpenAlex : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Independent sources

Documents or observations whose evidence does not simply derive from the same repeated report. Several pages based on one release are not several separate confirmations.

AFP Factuel : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Sponsored result

An identified advertising placement in search. It does not establish that the destination is official and is distinct from organic result ranking.

Google : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

URL host

The server name or IP address in hostname. Names in the path or parameters do not identify that host.

MDN Web Docs : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

URL user information

An optional part before @ in an address. A familiar name there does not establish that the host belongs to that organisation.

MDN Web Docs : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

URL fragment

The part introduced by #, used for a section or by an application. It does not establish page identity.

MDN Web Docs : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

CSV formula injection

Formula interpretation of a cell from an untrusted field. Protections depend on spreadsheet software and intended use; escaping is not a universal guarantee.

LibreOffice : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Evaluation scope

The pages, states and journeys examined. An automated result applies to that scope; it does not cover every human check.

W3C Web Accessibility Initiative : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Third-party connection

A link between an account and another service for sign-in or data sharing. Identify type and scope before removing authorisation.

Google : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Access revocation

Removal of a sign-in or access authorisation. Do not assume it erases data already received by the third party.

Google : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Account deactivation

An action whose effects and reversibility depend on the service. Read stated differences from deletion before deciding.

CNIL : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Receipt acknowledgement

A document or message acknowledging receipt in the relevant procedure. Read its content; it is not automatically a favourable decision.

Service Public : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Operating carrier

The operator carrying out a journey segment. It can differ from the ticket seller; identify it when checking conditions.

Air France : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Compared total price

An amount for a defined need and period including necessary options and charges. Keep assumptions to compare equivalent offers.

Économie.gouv.fr : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Test protocol

A description of a test’s models, conditions, measurements and criteria. It explains the scope of a score or ranking.

Que Choisir Ensemble : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Weighting

The contribution assigned to a criterion in a summary or score. Read published weights; similar overall scores can describe different profiles.

Que Choisir Ensemble : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Search log

A record of databases, queries, filters, dates and selection decisions. It explains a search and its limits without guaranteeing completeness.

PubMed : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Sporting season

A period designated by the competition organiser. It need not match a calendar year; check its label, category and discipline.

Fédération Française de Tennis : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

PMID

An identifier for a PubMed record. It locates a biomedical reference without guaranteeing free full text or valid results.

PubMed : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Crossmark

A service displaying publisher-reported status, including corrections and retractions. Its presence does not guarantee quality.

Crossref : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Correction notice

A document reporting a publication change. Read its scope and keep its reference alongside the affected article.

Crossref : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Retraction

A notice withdrawing a publication from use as a valid scientific result. Describe status and reason according to the notice without adding accusations.

PubMed : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

HTTP 301 redirect

A response indicating a permanent move to another address. It describes a technical link, not proof of publisher continuity.

MDN Web Docs : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

HTTP 403 response

Access refused for the observed request. Automated restrictions or server configuration can explain it; it does not prove a site has closed.

MDN Web Docs : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Dated version address

A link locating a specific edition. Keep it alongside the latest-version address when you need both citation and change tracking.

W3C : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Working Draft

A published draft in the W3C standards process. Publication does not make it a Recommendation; check status, date and subsequent changes.

W3C : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

W3C Recommendation

A W3C standard status distinct from drafts and notes. Document status and browser implementation require separate checks.

W3C : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Citation timestamp

A locator for an audio or video passage. Associate it with a specific episode and check context; different editions may be edited differently.

France Culture : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Data edition

The year or edition associated with data. It may differ from publication year and the date you access the interface.

IGN : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Mastodon server

The server hosting a Mastodon account. It is part of the profile’s identity; keep the full address and read its rules.

Mastodon : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

DOI

An identifier for a documentary object. It helps find a record; it does not validate the document’s conclusions.

Crossref : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

ORCID iD

An identifier for a person in research. Keep the full address and compare attributed contributions with the publications.

ORCID : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

SIREN

Nine digits identifying a legal unit. One unit can have several establishments; preserve that distinction when matching records.

Annuaire des Entreprises : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

SIRET

Fourteen digits identifying an establishment. Its existence does not authenticate someone contacting you in its name.

Annuaire des Entreprises : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Bibliographic record

A description of a document: title, authors, publication and identifiers. A record and abstract are not the full text.

PubMed : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Preprint

A version shared to disseminate a work. Deposit and moderation do not establish scientific peer review.

arXiv : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Document version

The specific state of a document you read. Keep its number, date and file to recover passages and corrections.

HAL : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Reuse licence

Conditions permitting certain uses of content. Check the particular file’s terms, credits and any modifications.

Wikimedia Commons : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

ODbL

The OpenStreetMap data licence. Reuse obligations and tile-service policies are separate questions.

OpenStreetMap : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Public domain

A status to examine by work and territory. A book available in the United States may have different rights elsewhere.

Project Gutenberg : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Statistical indicator

A measure defined for a population and period. Compare unit, territory, method and dates before matching two values.

Insee : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Missing value

An absent or unpublished value. It is not zero; check table codes and available years.

Banque mondiale : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Weather vigilance

Information about dangerous phenomena within an area and period. Read bulletins together with the map and its updates.

Météo-France : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Archived screenshot

An image of a page at a past date. It does not establish its current state; an identification graphic is not a screenshot.

Internet Archive : uses and checks →

Read primary documentation ↗

Put the distinctions to work

Illustrative situations and the missing evidence
SituationNext check
A paper has a DOI but only its abstract is visible.Find the relevant full-text version before interpreting its methods or results.
A seller’s SIREN matches a real business.Check the establishment and contact independently: a copied identifier is possible.
A downloadable photograph is marked reusable.Read its precise licence, creator credit and conditions for your intended use.
Two countries have different values for an indicator.Match definition, unit and year; identify missing data before making the comparison.
An uninstalled app remains connected to an account.Read the connection type and scope in official account settings before removing access.
A draft form is saved but submission is unconfirmed.Check the submission stage and retain the reference supplied by the service.
Two products have similar overall test scores.Compare detailed criteria, weighting and exact models against your needs.

Examine the catalogue fields →

Choose a complete task pathway →